Dupe perfumes: what they are, how they are made and why they cost less

The truth behind dupe and equivalent perfumes: how they are created, how close they get to the original, where they fall short and what to check before buying.

A 100 ml bottle of a designer perfume can cost more than €120, and its dupe less than €20. It is natural to wonder how that is possible and whether they really smell the same. The short answer is that a dupe perfume tries to reproduce the scent of another one, but without the brand, without the designer bottle and without most of the costs that come with them. The long answer has nuances worth knowing before you buy.

What exactly is a dupe perfume

A dupe perfume (also called an equivalent, clone or alternative) is a fragrance created to resemble another one that already exists and is usually well known. The shop does not sell the original perfume and has no connection with its brand: it sells its own composition designed to smell similar. That is why almost every shop identifies its perfumes with a number or a reference and explains, separately, which perfume inspired it.

This kind of product must not be confused with counterfeits. A counterfeit copies the name, the logo and the bottle to pass itself off as the original, and selling it is illegal. A dupe perfume is sold under its own brand and in its own packaging, and does not try to mislead anyone about who makes it.

How a dupe is created

The starting point is usually a chemical analysis of the original perfume. With techniques such as gas chromatography coupled with mass spectrometry, a laboratory can identify many of the molecules in a fragrance and their approximate proportions. From there, a perfumer rebuilds the formula with raw materials available on the market.

That analysis does not solve everything. Perfumes contain very complex natural ingredients (a rose essential oil can have hundreds of components), bases that the big houses make exclusively and patented molecules. When the same ingredient cannot be used, the perfumer replaces it with a similar one. Those substitutions explain the small differences some noses notice: a flatter opening, a sweeter base or a different evolution after a few hours.

Why they cost so much less

The liquid is only a small part of the price of a designer perfume. A large share goes on advertising, famous faces for the campaigns, elaborate bottles and boxes, distribution to department stores and the margin of every intermediary. A dupe shop does without almost all of that: standard bottles, little advertising and direct sales, often online.

That does not mean quality is always the same. Between shops there are real differences in concentration, in the quality of raw materials and in the care with which each formula has been rebuilt. That is why comparing makes sense: not all dupes of the same perfume are equal, and they do not cost the same.

Do they smell the same as the original?

It depends on the perfume and on the shop. Fragrances built on a few very recognisable molecules, such as many fresh masculine scents or sweet perfumes with lots of vanilla and ethyl maltol, are relatively easy to reproduce, and their dupes tend to come very close. Compositions with many natural ingredients, such as classic chypres or high-end rose perfumes, are harder, and the differences show more.

It is worth having realistic expectations: a good dupe clearly recalls the original and can pass for it day to day, but compared side by side on the skin it is common to notice nuances. The evolution also changes: an original may have a brighter opening or a longer base, and the dupe a more linear profile.

What to check before buying

Is it legal to sell dupe perfumes?

Selling your own fragrance that smells like another one is not prohibited, because a scent on its own cannot be registered as a trademark in the European Union. What is restricted is the use of other people's trademarks: in 2009 the Court of Justice of the EU ruled (L'Oréal v Bellure) that comparative advertising cannot present a product as an imitation or replica of a trademarked one. That is why shops avoid copying bottles and logos, and are careful about how they mention the original perfumes. This is a general explanation, not legal advice.

At Divainary we mention the names of the original perfumes only as a reference so you can find their dupes, and the brands belong to their owners.

How to use this comparison

Search for the original perfume you like and open its page: you will see every dupe we have found in the shops we follow, with its reference, size, price and price per millilitre, sorted from cheapest to most expensive per ml. If you do not know where to start, try our Find your perfume quiz or explore the fragrance families.

Prices change often. The ones we show are those published by each shop at the last update; the final price is always the shop's.

Perfumes to start with

← Back to the blog